Marchman Act Checklist: Sibling Refusing Care Between Crises

If your brother or sister keeps refusing care between crises, you may be asking whether a court can step in. In Florida, the Marchman Act may let a relative ask a court to order an assessment and treatment when substance use is the core problem. This checklist helps you sort your facts. Only a court decides whether the law applies.

Where you are right now: a sibling who keeps refusing help

Each crisis leaves you cleaning up after someone who won’t accept help. You may be handling the calls, the emergency room trips, and the bills. Your biggest fears are likely the ones many families name: irreversible harm, money being taken, dangerous decisions, and another hospitalization.

This page gives you a yes/no checklist. It shows whether your sibling’s situation may fit a Marchman Act petition. Your sibling is the person with the problem. You are the one searching for a lawful way to help.

What the Marchman Act is and who it is for

The Marchman Act is Florida’s law for court-ordered assessment and treatment of people impaired by substance use. Under § 397.675, a person may meet the criteria for involuntary admission when there is a good faith reason to believe the person is substance abuse impaired, or has a substance use disorder and a co-occurring mental health disorder, and the criteria below result from that impairment or disorder. That impairment must have caused the person to lose self-control over substance use.

The Act is about substance use. A case driven by mental illness alone raises a different legal question. Raise that at your consultation if mental health is the main issue.

Families often turn to this law after a pattern: repeated refusal of treatment, relapse with dangerous results, or an inability to meet basic needs.

Marchman Act eligibility checklist for a sibling in Florida

Answer each question yes or no. A no is useful information too.

1. Is substance use the core problem? The Marchman Act turns on substance use impairment. If yes, keep going. If no, the main issue may need a different legal path.

2. Has your relative refused care, medication, or a scheduled appointment? If so, write down each refusal and its date.

3. Has your sibling shown dangerous behavior or an inability to meet basic needs? Examples include unsafe driving, missed medication, losing housing, or going without food or care. If yes, note each event with a date.

4. Have crises repeated? A pattern of emergency visits, overdoses or hospital stays is easier to present than one event. If yes, list them in order.

5. If yes, you have the core of a timeline. If no, start one today.

6. Has your relative had repeated psychiatric hospitalizations or refused care? If so, ask our attorneys whether a Marchman Act petition may apply to your situation.

7. Has your sibling had a recent professional assessment? If yes, gather that report. If no, note that too. For an adult, a petition for involuntary treatment services may be filed by the respondent’s spouse or legal guardian, any relative, a service provider, or an adult who has direct personal knowledge of the respondent’s substance abuse impairment and his or her prior course of assessment and treatment (§ 397.68112). If there was no assessment, or your sibling refused one, the petition must say so. If yes, gather that report. If no, note that too.

Scoring: Mostly yes on items 1 through 6 suggests the Marchman Act may be worth a detailed legal review. A no on item 1 points to a different path. The checklist does not decide eligibility.

What to do with your results

Your answers tell you what to gather next, not whether to file.

  • Mostly yes: Write a dated timeline. Gather records you can lawfully access, such as discharge papers, police or EMS reports, and medication lists. List who saw the behavior.
  • Mixed answers: Keep the timeline anyway. Mixed answers often point to a co-occurring mental health condition that needs a closer look.
  • Mostly no: Bring your notes to a consultation and ask which legal path fits.
  • Immediate danger: Call 911 now. A petition does not replace emergency response.

How a Marchman Act petition works: steps and timeline

A petition starts when a qualified relative files with the court clerk.

  1. Gather facts and records. Build the timeline from the checklist.
  2. Prepare the petition. It must include names, your relationship to your sibling, the attorney if known, and the factual allegations (§ 397.68141).
  3. File with the clerk in the right county. File where your sibling is physically located. The clerk may not charge a filing fee under § 397.681. The Miami-Dade Clerk of the Court directs adult cases to its Probate Court.
  4. Hearing. The court schedules a hearing within 10 court working days unless a continuance is granted (§ 397.68151). Your sibling receives notice.
  5. Counsel and assessment. Your sibling has the right to counsel at every stage, though they may waive it if they are present and the court finds the waiver knowing, intelligent, and voluntary (§ 397.681).
  6. Burden of proof. The petitioner must prove the case by clear and convincing evidence (§ 397.6957). Plan to attend and present your facts yourself.
  7. Treatment order and renewal. If the court grants the petition, it may order up to 90 days of treatment (§ 397.697). A renewal petition must be filed before that period ends (§ 397.6975).

In an emergency, the court may enter an assessment order based on the petition alone (§ 397.6818). Timing depends on the facts and the court’s calendar, so ask about your county at your consultation.

What the consultation includes and what it costs

Robinson Casey limits its practice to Marchman Act petitions and guardianship matters for families across South Florida and statewide. Richard J. Casey III, Esq., is the responsible attorney for this page. Our team handles intake and scheduling.

The first consultation is free, confidential, and comes with no obligation to continue. In that meeting, you can review your checklist answers, ask about your options, and learn what costs may apply. A court may prohibit, or a law enforcement agency may waive, service of process fees for an indigent petitioner (§ 397.68112).

Common questions from families like yours

Can your sibling be ordered into treatment without a hearing?

In most cases, the court sets a hearing within 10 court working days. Emergency orders follow a different track.

Does your sibling have a right to a lawyer?

Yes. A respondent has the right to counsel at every stage, unless the respondent is present and the court finds that he or she knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily waives it. A respondent who wants counsel and cannot afford a private lawyer has the right to a court-appointed lawyer. If the court believes the respondent needs or wants counsel, the court must appoint one without regard to the respondent’s wishes.

Are Marchman Act records private?

Petitions and related court records are confidential and exempt from public records (§ 397.6760).

Is guardianship the same thing?

No. Guardianship is a separate court process for decision-making authority. The Marchman Act focuses on assessment and treatment for substance use.

Other states have their own laws for similar situations.

Talk through your sibling’s situation with Robinson Casey

If your brother or sister keeps leaving care and the crises keep returning, you are carrying a heavy load. You don’t have to sort out the legal side alone. Bring your checklist answers and dated notes to a first conversation with Robinson Casey, and call (561) 849-4149 to schedule it.

The information on this website is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or create an attorney-client relationship. Results in prior cases do not guarantee similar outcomes in future matters. Please consult a licensed Florida attorney for advice specific to your situation. Robinson Casey, 6400 Congress Ave #2050, Boca Raton, FL 33487.

Related practice areas

Call Now — Free Consultation (561) 849-4700