Spouse Denies Drinking Problem: Florida Court Treatment
When your spouse drinks every day and insists nothing is wrong, the whole household can start to feel unsafe. Money gets tight, moods swing, and you lie awake wondering what the children are seeing.
Florida law gives a spouse a court route for this situation. Under the Marchman Act, a judge can order an adult into assessment and, when the legal test is met, into treatment, even if that adult refuses. Your spouse’s denial matters, but it does not end the question. The judge looks at the statute’s criteria and the evidence.
When your spouse drinks daily and says there is no problem
Denial does not mean your family has to wait for your spouse to decide to change.
Under Florida’s involuntary admission criteria, a person’s refusal of services is not, by itself, evidence that the person lacks judgment about needing them. A judge looks past the refusal to the facts. Those facts include impairment, loss of self-control, and the risk of harm.
Money pressure, unpredictable behavior, and fear for the children are real strains. They matter to your family. The court’s test, though, centers on specific facts about impairment and harm.
Below, you’ll find what the law allows, how a petition is built, how a case moves, and where the process has limits.
Can a Florida court order alcohol treatment for someone who refuses it?
Yes, a Florida court can order involuntary assessment, stabilization, and treatment when the Marchman Act criteria are proved. The court may order treatment for up to 90 days when the conditions are proved by clear and convincing evidence. If the conditions justifying involuntary treatment services are expected to exist after 90 days of treatment services, a renewal may be requested under involuntary treatment order rules before the end of the 90-day period.
A spouse can file. The statute lists a respondent’s spouse or legal guardian, any relative, a service provider, and an adult who has direct personal knowledge of the impairment and of the respondent’s prior course of assessment and treatment. See who may petition in Florida. See who may petition in Florida.
A court order is not automatic. The judge decides based on the petition, the evidence at the hearing, and the statute’s test.
What a petition has to show and what to document now
A petition has to state facts, not just worries. It must name both of you, describe your relationship, and name your spouse’s attorney if known. See what a petition must contain.
A petition may include a report from a qualified professional who examined your spouse within 30 days before filing. If your spouse was not assessed or refused, the petition must say so.
Your petition must contain the name of your spouse, your name as petitioner, the relationship between you, the name of your spouse’s attorney if known, and the factual allegations establishing the need for involuntary services. A person who knowingly makes a false declaration commits a felony of the third degree, under perjury by written declaration.
Start your record now:
- A dated log of specific incidents: what happened, when, and who saw it.
- Texts, voicemails, and emails that show the drinking or the behavior.
- Records of missing money, unpaid bills, or missed work you know about firsthand.
- Photos, only where taking them is lawful.
- Names of people who saw the events firsthand.
Write facts, not guesses. Exaggeration hurts credibility. Knowingly making a false written declaration under penalties of perjury is a third-degree felony. Keep the children out of this work. Don’t ask them to keep logs, take photos, or pick sides.
How a Marchman Act case moves, step by step
A case usually starts with a sworn petition. The court must set a hearing within 10 court working days unless it grants a continuance, under court duties after filing.
- Consultation. Contact us to discuss your situation in a free, confidential first consultation, with no obligation to continue.
- A wrong-county filing does not automatically end the case. A wrong-county filing ruling held that the court kept jurisdiction.
- Notice and counsel. Your spouse receives the petition and the notice of hearing. Your spouse may have a lawyer. The court decides whether your spouse is already represented or whether appointing counsel is appropriate. A Second District ruling in Hillsborough County v. Albrechta found that due process supports the right to counsel.
- Emergency orders. In an emergency, the court may rely on the petition alone and enter an ex parte order for assessment and stabilization, under ex parte assessment orders. A provider generally may not hold your spouse for more than 72 hours of observation, subject to listed exceptions. If your spouse does not appear at the hearing and the court issues or reissues a 90-day ex parte assessment order, and your spouse’s location is known at the time of the hearing, the court must continue the case for no more than 10 court working days. Otherwise, you must tell the court once your spouse has been assessed so it can schedule a hearing, and the court must dismiss the case if your spouse has not been assessed within 90 days. An ex parte order must rest on facts giving a good-faith reason to believe the criteria are met, as D.H. v. K.J.R. explains.
- Hearing. Testimony is taken under oath and recorded. The court reviews relevant evidence, including testimony from family members who know your spouse’s history. The court may also order drug tests, under hearing rules.
What the Marchman Act does not do
The statute also provides for early release once the reasons for treatment no longer exist, under early release rules.
- Be ready to present your case. Under Fifth District decisions, a judge may not call and question a health care professional to supply an absent petitioner’s case. The Fourth District has certified conflict with that rule in J.J.J. v. D.G., and the 2024 amendments may affect that dispute. So this rule is Fifth District law, not a settled statewide rule.
- Outcomes vary. No one can promise how a judge will rule or how your spouse will respond to treatment.
Protecting the children and the household while the case moves
The strongest way to protect your children is a petition that describes their risk in specific, factual terms. Include dates and what each child saw or experienced. Judges weigh facts, not labels. Describe what happened, not what you think it means.
Court records in these cases are confidential. The clerk may release them only to listed people, including the petitioner, the respondent, and their attorneys, under court record confidentiality.
Keep copies of shared bank statements, bills, and receipts. They show where household money is going. Talk through steps to protect shared money during your consultation.
Keep school, medical, and daily routines steady for the children. Name a trusted adult who knows what is happening at home.
Why families work with Robinson Casey
Robinson Casey limits its practice to Marchman Act petitions, involuntary commitment for addiction, and guardianship matters.
Richard J. Casey III, Esq. is the responsible lawyer for this page. The firm’s lawyers and support staff handle these matters for families across South Florida, including Miami-Dade, and statewide.
The first meeting covers three things:
- The facts you’ve documented and where they are thin.
- Your children’s safety and the household’s immediate concerns.
- Which petition options fit your situation.
The first consultation is free, confidential, and comes with no obligation to continue.
Frequently asked questions
Short answers to common questions from spouses in your position.
Can my spouse be forced into treatment if they say they are fine?
Do I need a lawyer to file a Marchman Act petition?
A lawyer can help you prepare the sworn petition and speak for you at the hearing. Under § 397.68151(1), Florida Statutes, the court determines whether your spouse is represented or whether appointing counsel is appropriate.
Will my spouse find out before a hearing?
Yes. Your spouse must receive a copy of the petition and the notice of the hearing.
Can a Marchman Act order cover alcohol as well as other drugs?
The statute covers substance abuse impairment, so drinking can fall within it when the criteria are met.
Talk with Robinson Casey about your family’s situation
The next step is a conversation about your facts. You have been carrying this alone while your spouse insists nothing is wrong. Deciding what to do is hard, and you don’t have to sort it all out on your own first. Bring your log, your questions about the children, and your worries about money. Call (561) 849-4149 or request a consultation online.
