Florida Drug Court or the Marchman Act: Which Path Fits You?
Your loved one’s drinking or drug use has started to involve the courts. Maybe a criminal charge is pending. Maybe you’ve asked them to get help, and they keep saying no.
The Marchman Act is a civil process that a family member can start with a petition. Which one fits depends on the facts in front of you, and the two sometimes overlap.
This page explains how each path works, what a violation means, how long each one lasts, and how to sort your own facts. Getting the path right early helps you ask better questions.
Two Paths, Two Different Starting Points
Drug court and the Marchman Act both address substance use, but they begin in different places. Drug court starts with a criminal case. The Marchman Act starts with a petition filed in court.
Many families assume the two are interchangeable. They are not. Florida law lets each county fund a treatment-based drug court program for people in the justice system who are assessed with a substance abuse problem. It gives certain people a way to ask a court for involuntary treatment for an adult who is substance abuse impaired.
So check one fact first: is a criminal case already open? That answer changes which path you are asking about. The sections below walk through how each process works, starting with drug court.
How Does Drug Court Work in Florida?
Drug court in Florida is a court-supervised treatment program for people whose substance use is tied to a justice case. Each county may fund one. The statute says people in the justice system who are assessed with a substance abuse problem can be processed through it, with treatment tailored to their needs (Fla. Stat. § 397.334).
A program can include pretrial intervention and postadjudicatory programs. It can also review how sentenced offenders are doing in treatment (§ 397.334). Florida also runs dependency drug courts for some family substance use cases in child welfare matters (dependency drug court standards).
Once a person enrolls, a drug court team sets a coordinated strategy for them. The team must give that strategy to the participant in writing before the participant agrees to enter. Prosecution and defense counsel both take part. The approach is nonadversarial. Both sides aim to promote public safety while protecting the participant’s due process rights (§ 397.334).
What Happens If Someone Violates a Drug Court Program?
A violation of probation or community control by a postadjudicatory drug court participant is heard by the judge presiding over that program, who disposes of it, after a hearing or admission, as the judge deems appropriate if the resulting sentence or conditions are lawful (§ 397.334). The coordinated strategy may include a protocol of sanctions for noncompliance with program rules (§ 397.334).
Those sanctions may include placement in a substance abuse treatment program offered by a licensed provider. They may also include a jail-based treatment program, secure detention under chapter 985 for a child, or, for an adult, a period of incarceration within the time limits established for contempt of court. The statute uses the word “may,” so the exact response comes from the program’s strategy and the court.
Read the written strategy before you agree to anything. The statute requires it in writing before entry, so the terms exist on paper. Keep the court’s notices together so you and your loved one can see every term and deadline.
Referral programs have their own safeguards. The director must communicate a refusal immediately to the referral source, or a discharge immediately to both the offender and the referral source, and explain the decision in writing, stating its basis, within 72 hours (Fla. Stat. § 397.705).
How Long Does Drug Court Last in Florida?
Each program sets its own schedule under its coordinated strategy, so the length varies by program and by case.
One statewide limit does apply to court referrals. For a person charged with or convicted of a crime, the total treatment time may not exceed the maximum sentence possible for that offense (§ 397.705). The referral order must be in writing and must state the duration of the sentence. When treatment is complete or the time runs out, the program director must tell the referral source.
The Marchman Act runs on its own clock. If a court finds the conditions proved by clear and convincing evidence, it may order involuntary treatment for up to 90 days (§ 397.697). If the conditions justifying treatment are expected to continue after 90 days, a renewal can be requested before that period ends. The service provider may file a renewal petition, or the person who filed the original petition may do so if it is accompanied by supporting documentation from the service provider (§ 397.6975).
How the Marchman Act Works
The Marchman Act lets certain people ask a court to order involuntary treatment for an adult who is substance abuse impaired. It starts with a civil petition, not a criminal charge.
Who can file? For an adult, the petition can come from a spouse or legal guardian, any relative, a service provider, or an adult with direct personal knowledge of the person’s impairment and prior treatment (§ 397.68112). For a minor, a parent, legal guardian, or service provider may file.
What must the petition say? It names the respondent and the petitioner and states their relationship. The court looks for a good faith reason to believe the statutory criteria are met (§ 397.675).
Where do you file? The petition goes with the clerk in the county where the person is located. The clerk may not charge a fee for filing it (§ 397.681). In Miami-Dade, the Clerk directs adult petitions to Probate Court (Miami-Dade Clerk). A Fifth District case held that a wrong-county filing is a venue defect, not a loss of jurisdiction (J.P. v. J.N.).
The respondent has the right to counsel at every stage, unless the respondent waives it while present and the court finds the waiver knowing, intelligent, and voluntary (§ 397.681). In an emergency, the court may enter an ex parte order for assessment and stabilization based on the petition alone, without appointing an attorney (§ 397.6818). At the hearing, testimony is taken under oath. The court may order drug tests, and the respondent may refuse to testify (§ 397.6957).
Side-by-Side: The Key Differences
Drug court runs inside a criminal case, while the Marchman Act starts a separate civil matter. The table shows the main differences.
| Drug court | Marchman Act | |
|---|---|---|
| How it starts | Referral within a criminal case | Petition filed with the clerk |
| Who starts it | A court or criminal justice authority | A spouse, legal guardian, relative, service provider, or adult with direct knowledge |
| Legal setting | Criminal justice system | Civil court |
| What triggers it | A charge, conviction, or program terms | A good faith reason to believe the statutory criteria are met |
| Length | Set by each program; referral time capped by the sentence | Up to 90 days, with renewal possible |
Use the table to sort your facts. Then check each row against what is actually happening in your family’s situation.
Can a Marchman Act Petition Run Alongside Criminal Proceedings?
A Marchman Act petition does not replace criminal proceedings. The two are separate matters that run on separate tracks.
A petition does not resolve pending charges. A court may still refer a person charged with a crime to a licensed service provider. That referral is in addition to any sentence or other action (§ 397.705). The criminal side keeps its own rules, even when a civil petition is open.
Questions about the charge itself belong with the defense counsel in that criminal case. Questions about the petition belong to the civil matter. Keep track of which court handles each matter and who represents you in each one.
Some families face both situations at once. When that happens, review the facts of both together. Don’t assume one will settle the other.
Which Path Fits Your Loved One’s Situation?
Start by asking whether a criminal case is open, because that fact points toward drug court. If no case is open and your loved one refuses help, the question may be a Marchman Act petition.
Three questions help sort the facts:
- Is there a pending criminal case, charge, or sentence?
- Is your loved one willing to enter treatment?
- Has your loved one refused help while showing signs of lost self-control or impaired judgment (§ 397.675)?
Which path fits depends on the facts. A loved one with an open case may raise a drug court question. A loved one who will not accept treatment may raise a Marchman question. Some families need both reviewed together.
Is drug court the same as the Marchman Act?
No. Drug court is a treatment program inside a criminal case. The Marchman Act is a civil petition for involuntary treatment.
Who can file a Marchman Act petition for an adult?
A spouse, legal guardian, relative, service provider, or adult who has direct personal knowledge of the adult’s substance abuse impairment and prior course of assessment and treatment can file a petition for that adult.
Does a Marchman Act petition cost money to file?
The clerk may not charge a fee for filing the petition (§ 397.681).
How long can involuntary treatment last?
A court may order up to 90 days of involuntary treatment after clear and convincing evidence, and a renewal can be requested before that period ends if the conditions justifying treatment are expected to exist after 90 days (§ 397.697).
Talk Through Your Loved One’s Situation With Robinson Casey
If your loved one has an open criminal case, keeps refusing help, or both, and you can’t tell which path applies, we can talk through the facts with you.
Robinson Casey is a Florida law firm that focuses on Marchman Act petitions and guardianship matters. It serves families across South Florida and statewide. Richard J. Casey III, Esq. is the responsible attorney for this page.
If your loved one was recently assessed, a report from a qualified professional may accompany a petition when it was done within 30 days before filing (§ 397.68141). Bring any records you have to the conversation.
The first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation to continue. To schedule, call (561) 849-4149 or reach us through our contact page.
