Marchman or Guardianship: Adult Addiction or Mental Illness
When a loved one’s drinking, drug use, or mental illness puts them at risk, you may wonder whether a court can step in. In Florida, the Marchman Act is the court route for substance use impairment. Guardianship is the court route for an adult found incapacitated, including because of mental illness.
This page explains how each path works, how to tell which may fit your facts, and what the process involves.
The Marchman Act and Guardianship Are Different Tools
The Marchman Act addresses substance use. Guardianship addresses incapacity. The two can overlap, but they follow separate statutes.
Under § 397.675, a person may meet the criteria for involuntary admission when there is good faith reason to believe they are substance abuse impaired, or have a substance use disorder and a co-occurring mental health disorder. Their impairment must also have taken away their power of self-control. Fla. Stat. § 397.675 reads: “(b) Without care or treatment, is likely to suffer from neglect or refuse to care for himself or herself; that such neglect or refusal poses a real and present threat of substantial harm to his or her well-being; and that it is not apparent that such harm may be avoided through the help of willing, able, and responsible family members or friends or the provision of other services, or there is substantial likelihood that the person has inflicted, or threatened to or attempted to inflict, or, unless admitted, is likely to inflict, physical harm on himself, herself, or another.”
Guardianship falls under Chapter 744. A petition to determine incapacity must be verified and must describe the facts behind the belief that the adult is incapacitated (§ 744.3201). The court then appoints a three-member examining committee. One member must be a psychiatrist or other physician (§ 744.331).
Overlap can happen. An adult may have a substance use problem alongside a psychiatric condition. For the broader picture, read our Marchman Act overview.
How Do You Tell Which Path May Fit?
Start with the main problem. Substance use that harms health or safety points toward the Marchman Act. An adult who cannot make safe decisions about money, medical care, or daily life points toward guardianship.
Facts that point toward the Marchman Act:
- Substance use is damaging health, work, housing, or safety.
- The adult refuses help or cannot see the need for it.
- There has been a recent threat, attempt, or pattern of harm.
Facts that point toward guardianship:
- The adult cannot manage property or pay bills safely.
- The adult cannot make health care or living-arrangement decisions.
- The cause is mental illness or another incapacity, not only substance use.
Location matters too. Miami-Dade directs people seeking involuntary alcohol or drug treatment to the Clerk’s Office Probate Court for adults, according to the Miami-Dade Clerk. Before you call, write down dates and incidents. Our guide on documenting drug use for a petition explains what to gather.
Which Guardianship Types Does Robinson Casey Handle?
Robinson Casey focuses on emergency temporary, plenary, limited, and mental health guardianship for families in South Florida and statewide.
Emergency Temporary Guardianship
A court can appoint an emergency temporary guardian after a petition for incapacity is filed. The court must find imminent danger to the person’s health or safety, or to property, unless immediate action is taken (§ 744.3031). The authority ends 90 days after appointment or when a guardian is appointed, whichever comes first. It can be extended for another 90 days if emergency conditions still exist.
Plenary and Limited Guardianship
Florida law lets an incapacity order remove certain rights and give some of them to a guardian. Rights that can be delegated include contracting, managing property, determining residence, and making health care decisions (§ 744.3215). A limited guardianship leaves more of the adult’s rights in place. A plenary guardianship covers a broader set of them.
Mental Health Guardianship
The comprehensive examination must include, if indicated, a physical examination and a mental health examination (§ 744.331). A guardian cannot commit the ward to a facility, institution, or licensed service provider without first getting specific court authority and a formal placement proceeding under chapter 393, chapter 394, or chapter 397 (§ 744.3215).
How Does the Process Work, Step by Step?
The process moves from consultation to records, a petition, notice, a hearing, and an order. Each path follows its own statutory steps.
- Consultation. We review the facts, timeline, and records you have. The initial consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation to continue.
- Records. Gather dates, specific incidents, treatment records, and provider names. A petition may include a report from a qualified professional who examined the person within 30 days before filing (§ 397.68141).
- Filing. A Marchman petition is filed with the clerk in the county where the person is located (§ 397.681).
- The respondent has a right to counsel at every stage of a Marchman proceeding, which the respondent may waive only if present and the court finds the waiver is knowing, intelligent, and voluntary (§ 397.681). A Florida appellate court has held that due process supports that right (Hillsborough County v. Albrechta).
- Hearing. The petitioner must prove the case by clear and convincing evidence (§ 397.6957). The respondent generally must attend. Witnesses may testify remotely under oath, as appropriate, but a witness who plans to do so must give the parties all relevant documents by the close of business on the day before the hearing.
- Order. The court either dismisses the petition or orders treatment. A treatment order must include findings on the need for treatment and on less restrictive alternatives (§ 397.6957).
Timing depends on the facts and the court’s calendar.
Can Someone Be Forced Into Treatment, and How Long Does It Last?
Florida law allows a court to order involuntary treatment for substance abuse impairment. The court can do so only after the statutory standard is proved on the basis of clear and convincing evidence.
An initial treatment order can last up to 90 days (§ 397.697). If the conditions are expected to exist after 90 days of treatment, a renewal of the involuntary services order may be requested under s. 397.6975 before the 90-day period ends. A renewal can add up to another 90 days (§ 397.6975). The person must be released early once the conditions justifying treatment no longer exist (§ 397.6971).
Guardianship runs on its own schedule. A guardian of the person files an annual guardianship plan. Fla. Stat. § 744.367 reads: “(2) Unless the court requires or authorizes filing on a fiscal-year basis, each guardian of the property shall file with the court an annual accounting on or before April 1 of each year.” The adult keeps the right to an annual review of the report and plan, and to be restored to capacity at the earliest possible time (§ 744.3215).
The hearing is not a formality. In R.S. v. C.P.T., the Fifth District ordered a new hearing after a judge helped a family petitioner prove the case.
Why Families Work With Robinson Casey
Robinson Casey focuses exclusively on Marchman Act petitions and guardianship matters. That keeps our work in two areas of Florida law.
Richard J. Casey III, Esq. is the responsible lawyer for this page. Our lawyers handle these matters for families in Miami-Dade, South Florida, and statewide. Our team includes assistants and office staff.
A focused practice means:
- Filing details get attention, including the county rule and the basis for an emergency order.
- Your loved one’s rights stay in view, including counsel, notice, and the right to review.
Questions Families Ask Before Deciding
A court makes these decisions, not the family. Both the Marchman Act and guardianship require a judge to find specific facts first.
Can a mentally ill adult be forced to get help in Florida?
A court can order help only when the legal standard is met and proved on the basis of clear and convincing evidence.
What does a Marchman Act petition need?
It must name the respondent and the petitioner, state their relationship, and list the facts showing why services are needed (§ 397.68141).
How long does a Marchman Act order last?
An initial order can last up to 90 days. A renewal may be requested before the 90-day period ends (§ 397.697).
Does a respondent have the right to a lawyer?
Yes. A respondent who desires counsel and cannot afford private counsel has the right to court-appointed counsel (§ 397.681).
What happens at the first consultation?
We review your facts, timeline, and records. That shows you which path may fit.
You may still be weighing your options while your loved one’s safety is on your mind. When you’re ready, contact Robinson Casey or call (561) 849-4149 to talk through your situation.
