Your Brother Still Using: Florida Involuntary Addiction
If your brother has been hospitalized again and is still using, you may be asking whether a court can step in. The Marchman Act lets certain family members ask a judge to order assessment and treatment for an adult with a substance use impairment.
A brother or sister counts as a relative under Florida’s list of who may file. That means you may be able to start the process yourself. Whether the court orders treatment turns on the evidence the judge hears.
What the Marchman Act Is and Who It Is For
It starts with a petition filed in court. The person named in the petition is called the respondent.
Under Fla. Stat. § 397.68112, an adult’s petition may be filed by a spouse or legal guardian, any relative, a service provider, or an adult who has direct personal knowledge of the impairment and of the person’s prior course of assessment and treatment. A brother or sister fits within “any relative.”
The petition goes to the clerk of court in the county where the person is located, under Fla. Stat. § 397.681.
Why Hospitalized and Still Using Changes the Picture
Repeated hospital stays followed by continued use give a court a concrete record to review. Each visit is a fact you can document.
Many families describe the same cycle. A crisis leads to emergency care or a short stay. The person is discharged, and use resumes. It can feel like the visit closed the matter, but the records stay open.
A petition has to state the facts. It must give the reason you believe your brother is impaired and has lost the power of self-control. It must also explain why you believe he has inflicted or is likely to inflict physical harm on himself or others unless the court orders involuntary services, or why his refusal of care comes from judgment so impaired by substance abuse that he cannot appreciate his need for care and make a rational decision about it, as set out in Fla. Stat. § 397.68141.
Write down dates, facility names, discharge papers, and what happened before and after each stay. Note any police contact, overdose, or incident linked to use. If he was never assessed or refused an evaluation, the petition must say so. A common mistake is relying on memory after the fifth or sixth visit. Write the timeline now, while the details are fresh.
Marchman Act vs. Baker Act: Which Law Fits
The Marchman Act covers substance use impairment, and the Baker Act covers mental illness. The two laws overlap in some cases.
The Baker Act’s involuntary examination, in Fla. Stat. § 394.463, applies when there is reason to believe a person has a mental illness and, because of that illness, meets the statute’s criteria. The person must either have refused voluntary examination after a conscientious explanation of its purpose, or be unable to determine for himself or herself whether examination is necessary; and must also either be likely to neglect himself or herself or refuse care, a real and present threat of substantial harm with no apparent way to avoid it through willing, able family, friends, or other services, or have a substantial likelihood of causing serious bodily harm to himself, herself, or others in the near future, as shown by recent behavior.
The Marchman criteria are in Fla. Stat. § 397.675. They cover a person who is substance abuse impaired, or who has a substance use disorder and a co-occurring mental health disorder. Some families face both problems at once.
Which law fits depends on the facts. A hospital stay for mental health does not answer the substance use question by itself. The Florida courts’ Baker Act bench guide explains how examination, release, and placement work under that law.
How a Sibling Files a Marchman Act Petition, Step by Step
You prepare a petition, file it with the clerk in your brother’s county, and the court sets a hearing.
- Gather your records. Collect discharge papers, hospital dates, facility names, and notes on incidents tied to use.
- Confirm the county. File where your brother is physically located. If he is held in a Miami-Dade facility, the petition goes to the Miami-Dade clerk.
- Prepare the petition. It must name your brother and you, state your relationship, name his attorney if known, and set out the facts. You may attach a professional’s report from within 30 days before filing.
- Expect a hearing date. The court must schedule a hearing within 10 court working days unless a continuance is granted.
- Plan for an assessment. At the hearing, the court must hear and review all relevant evidence, including the results of the qualified professional’s assessment, and your brother must be present unless the court finds he knowingly, intelligently, and voluntarily waives that right or, after receiving proof of service and evaluating the circumstances, finds that his presence is inconsistent with his best interests or is likely to be injurious to self or others, per Fla. Stat. § 397.6957.
Timing varies by county and by case. No timeline can be promised.
What Courts Look for and What Happens After the Hearing
The court must find the conditions proved by clear and convincing evidence before it orders treatment.
The court keeps jurisdiction to monitor compliance and to address violations of its orders.
Florida law sets out criteria for involuntary admission. These include loss of the power of self-control with respect to substance abuse and being incapable of appreciating one’s need for services. Refusing services alone is not enough, the statute says.
At the hearing, testimony is under oath. Family members familiar with the history may testify. The judge may order drug tests. Your brother may refuse to testify.
Early release is possible. Under Fla. Stat. § 397.6971, a person may be discharged early on listed grounds, such as no longer meeting the criteria and agreeing to voluntary treatment.
When Guardianship May Be Part of the Picture
Guardianship is a separate court process. It can matter when addiction is not the only problem your brother faces.
An emergency temporary guardianship is the faster option. Under Fla. Stat. § 744.3031, a court may appoint one only after an incapacity petition is filed. The court must find imminent danger to health or safety, or danger to property, unless immediate action is taken.
Notice must reach the person and his attorney at least 24 hours before the hearing, unless the petitioner demonstrates that substantial harm to the alleged incapacitated person would occur if the 24-hour notice is given.
An emergency temporary guardian may be appointed only after a petition for determination of incapacity has been filed; this section does not set a three-member committee or a 5-day deadline for the longer process.
Plenary, limited, and mental health guardianship are longer-term paths within our practice. Each asks the court to decide how much authority a guardian should hold. The case decides which path fits.
Questions Siblings Ask Before Filing
Most sibling questions come down to who can file, where to file, and what the court can order.
Your standing should still be checked against your facts before you file.
Does my brother have to agree? No. The petition process exists for cases where the person does not accept voluntary care, and the judge decides after a hearing.
A lawyer can also review your records before you file.
What does the clerk charge? Nothing. The clerk may not charge a fee to file the petition, under Fla. Stat. § 397.681.
Why Work With Robinson Casey and Next Steps
Robinson Casey limits its practice to Marchman Act petitions and guardianship matters. The firm serves families in South Florida and statewide.
Richard J. Casey III, Esq. is the responsible lawyer for this page. Our team includes support staff who help families organize records and schedule consultations.
At a consultation, you bring your timeline and whatever records you have. The firm reviews whether a Marchman Act petition or a guardianship path may fit your family’s situation.
The first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation to continue. La consulta inicial es gratuita, confidencial y sin compromiso de continuar.
If your brother is back in the hospital and still using, you don’t have to sort out the court steps alone. Call (561) 849-4149 or request a consultation to talk through your options.
