Marchman Act Hearing: What If the Person Refuses to Attend?
Your loved one has a court date for a Marchman Act petition, and they have said they won’t go. That is a stressful place to be, and you probably want a clear answer fast.
Short answer: a Florida court can still move forward when the person does not show up. It can order an emergency assessment and direct law enforcement to take the person in for evaluation, but only when the statute’s conditions are met.
Why This Question Comes Up and What Happens Next
A court can keep the case moving when someone refuses to go to court, but only within the limits Chapter 397 sets.
The Marchman Act is Florida’s law for court-ordered assessment and treatment of a person whose substance abuse impairs their self-control and judgment. A petition must be filed with the clerk of court in the county where the person is located. The clerk may not charge a fee to file it (§ 397.681(1)). The person named is the respondent.
For an adult, a petition may be filed by a spouse or legal guardian, any relative, a service provider, or an adult who has direct personal knowledge of the person’s substance abuse impairment and his or her prior course of assessment and treatment (§ 397.68112(1)). If you are a parent, sibling, or adult child, you may be among those who can file.
For the full picture, start with our Marchman Act overview.
How the Person Is Notified of the Petition and Hearing
The person must receive a copy of the petition and a notice of the hearing. That notice is a core step before anything else happens.
Once a petition is filed, the court must set a hearing within 10 court working days unless a continuance is granted (§ 397.68151(2)). The clerk issues a summons. Unless the chief judge authorizes private process servers, the clerk sends the summons to a law enforcement agency within 6 hours so it can be served (§ 397.68151(3)).
Service also shapes what happens next. A missed hearing does not automatically end the case.
Why a Person May Refuse to Attend
A person may refuse to attend for many reasons. Florida law says a refusal alone does not prove a lack of judgment.
The statute states that mere refusal to receive substance abuse services does not, by itself, show lack of judgment about needing them (§ 397.675). Families often describe reasons like denial of a problem, fear of the process, anger at relatives, no ride, or confusion about the date.
Those reasons do not change the statutory test. The court looks at the facts in the petition. Under § 397.6957(1)(b), in nonemergency situations where the respondent was not, or had previously refused to be, assessed, the court shall issue an involuntary assessment and stabilization order if, based on the petition, testimony, and evidence presented, it reasonably appears that the respondent qualifies for involuntary treatment services. A facially insufficient petition requires dismissal (D.H. v. K.J.R.).
What the Court Can Do When the Person Does Not Attend
If the respondent does not appear at the hearing for any reason, including lack of service, the court may issue or reissue an ex parte assessment and stabilization order valid for 90 days if it reasonably believes the respondent meets the commitment criteria and that a substance abuse emergency exists, and, if the respondent’s location is known, may order a law enforcement officer or designated agent to take the person into custody and deliver them for evaluation.
An ex parte order is one the judge signs without the other side present. The order must be carried out while the hearing is pending (§ 397.6818(1)). The court may direct an officer or designated agent to take the person into custody and deliver them for evaluation (§ 397.6818(2)).
There are limits. An order not carried out by the first hearing date is void (§ 397.6818(4)). Fla. Stat. § 397.6818 reads: “(4) If the ex parte order was not executed by the initial hearing date, it is deemed void.” A provider generally may not hold the person more than 72 hours of observation unless a statutory exception applies (§ 397.6818(3)).
The petitioner carries the burden of proof. The Fourth District certified conflict on a related point, so check which district your case is in. Outcomes depend on the facts of each case.
Emergency Admission and How Long the Process Takes
An emergency admission can happen before the hearing when the required certificate and application are in place.
Under § 397.679, a person who meets the involuntary admission criteria may be admitted to a hospital, detox facility, or addictions receiving facility for emergency assessment. That requires a certificate from a listed clinician, such as a physician or clinical psychologist, that is specific to substance abuse impairment. It also requires an application for emergency admission.
There is no single timeline. Court-ordered treatment may last up to 90 days, and a renewal may be requested before that period ends (§ 397.697(1)(a)).
Rights and Protections for the Person Named in the Petition
The alleged impaired person is named as the respondent, and the involuntary treatment petition must be filed with the clerk of the court in the county where the person is located.
A respondent may waive counsel only if present and the court finds the waiver knowing, intelligent, and voluntary (§ 397.681(2)). A person who cannot afford a lawyer may ask the court to appoint one (§ 397.501(8)). The person’s lawyer has access to the person, witnesses, and relevant records.
The person generally must attend the hearing, unless the court finds a valid waiver or finds that presence is not in their best interests. No one may be ordered into involuntary treatment without a clinical assessment, unless the person is present and waives it (§ 397.6957(1)(b)).
Quick Answers to Common Questions
Can police bring someone to a hearing? Yes. If the person does not appear at the hearing for any reason, and their location is known, the court may direct a law enforcement officer or designated agent to take them into custody and deliver them for evaluation if the court reasonably believes they meet the commitment criteria and that a substance abuse emergency exists.
Can a Marchman Act petition be challenged? Yes. The person can contest the petition, and the court must find the conditions proved by clear and convincing evidence before ordering treatment.
Is there a 5150 hold in Florida? Florida’s mental health law is the Baker Act. The Marchman Act covers substance abuse impairment (Baker Act bench guide).
How long can a Marchman Act treatment order last? A treatment order may last up to 90 days.
Where a Treatment Order Fits In
The court may order treatment from a publicly funded provider. The court may also order treatment from a privately funded provider if the person can pay, or if any person on the person’s behalf voluntarily demonstrates a willingness and an ability to pay (§ 397.697(1)(a)). The court keeps jurisdiction to monitor compliance, change the treatment approach, or pursue contempt for violating a valid order (§ 397.697(2)).
Talk With Robinson Casey About Your Family’s Situation
If a hearing date is set and your loved one has not gone, you do not have to sort out the next step alone.
You may be waiting on a court date, unsure whether the person was served, and worried about what the court will do. Robinson Casey limits its practice to Marchman Act petitions and guardianship matters, serving families across South Florida and statewide. Richard J. Casey III, Esq. is the responsible lawyer for this page.
The initial consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation to continue. Call (561) 849-4149 or request a consultation to talk about the petition, the hearing, and the options that fit your facts.
