Can a Florida Court Keep Your Brother in Fentanyl Treatment?
Watching your brother leave treatment, then end up in another crisis, wears a family down. You may be asking whether a Florida court can step in when every voluntary plan falls apart.
Yes, a Florida court can order an adult into assessment and, if the legal findings are made, into involuntary treatment. Whether that fits your brother’s case depends on the facts. This page explains how the Marchman Act works so you can see what the court looks at.
Watching Your Brother Leave Treatment Again and Again
A court decides these cases by asking whether the statutory criteria are met, based on the full history of what has happened.
Each time your brother walks out, the same fear returns. Will the next call come from a hospital, or from the police? Fentanyl can turn one bad night into a medical emergency, and families often feel they are always waiting for the next one.
You may also be watching money disappear, housing slip away, or his judgment break down. Many families wait too long because they think the law only applies after a disaster. Florida’s statute looks at more than one kind of danger, including neglect and a risk of harm to himself or others. Feeling guilty about going to court is common, too. Asking for help does not mean you have failed him.
What the Marchman Act Allows a Florida Court to Do
The process has two stages. First, the court can order an assessment and stabilization. Second, if the required findings are proved, the court can order involuntary treatment.
Who can start it? For an adult, the law lets a spouse or legal guardian, any relative, a service provider, or an adult with direct personal knowledge of the impairment and his or her prior course of assessment and treatment file a petition (Fla. Stat. § 397.68112). Because your brother is your relative, you are among the people the law names. Being on that list does not mean the court will grant the petition.
Can a Court Order Your Brother to Stay in Treatment?
A court can order treatment only after it finds the statutory criteria are met, and leaving treatment on its own does not settle that question.
The core test is a good faith reason to believe the person is substance abuse impaired. Because of that impairment, the person must have lost the power of self-control with respect to substance abuse (§ 397.675). The law then requires one more finding. Either the person needs services and cannot appreciate that need, or the person is likely to neglect himself in a way that poses a real and present threat of substantial harm, and that harm is not apparently avoidable through the help of willing, able, and responsible family members or friends or other services. Fla. Stat. § 397.675 reads: “(b) Without care or treatment, is likely to suffer from neglect or refuse to care for himself or herself; that such neglect or refusal poses a real and present threat of substantial harm to his or her well-being; and that it is not apparent that such harm may be avoided through the help of willing, able, and responsible family members or friends or the provision of other services, or there is substantial likelihood that the person has inflicted, or threatened to or attempted to inflict, or, unless admitted, is likely to inflict, physical harm on himself, herself, or another.” A person who has inflicted, threatened or attempted physical harm can also meet this test.
The statute also says that mere refusal of services is not, by itself, evidence of lack of judgment. A court wants facts about what the person can understand and what risk he faces. Repeated departures from treatment are facts a court can weigh.
Courts also look at what has been tried. It may also order drug tests (§ 397.6957).
No one can predict how a court will rule on your brother’s record. Each case turns on its own facts.
How a Marchman Act Case Moves, Step by Step
A case moves from a written petition to a hearing, and then the court either dismisses the petition or orders the respondent to receive involuntary treatment services from his or her chosen licensed service provider if possible and appropriate; any treatment order must include findings on the respondent’s need for treatment and the appropriateness of less restrictive alternatives (§ 397.6957).
Step 1: File the Petition
The petition goes to the clerk in the county where your brother is located when it is filed. The clerk may not charge a fee for filing the petition (§ 397.681).
The alleged impaired person is named as the respondent, and the petition must also name you as petitioner and state your relationship to him (§ 397.68141). It must also give the reasons you believe he is substance abuse impaired, that because of this he has lost self-control over his substance use, and either that he has inflicted or is likely to inflict physical harm on himself or others unless the court orders services, or that his refusal of care comes from judgment so impaired by substance abuse that he cannot appreciate his need for care and cannot make a rational decision about that need (§ 397.68141). A report from a qualified professional who examined him within 30 days can go with it.
A provider may hold him for no more than 72 hours of observation, unless a listed exception applies.
Step 2: The Hearing
The court must set a hearing within 10 court working days, unless a continuance is granted (§ 397.68151). Your brother must receive a copy of the petition and notice of the hearing. He has the right to a lawyer at every stage, which he may waive if he is present and the court finds the waiver knowing, intelligent, and voluntary; if he desires counsel and cannot afford private counsel, he has the right to court-appointed counsel (§ 397.681).
He has the right to a lawyer at every stage of the proceeding, and he may waive that right if he is present and the court finds the waiver knowing, intelligent, and voluntary. His presence can also be excused if it is inconsistent with his best interests or likely to be injurious to himself or others (§ 397.6957).
The petitioner has the burden of proving by clear and convincing evidence the elements the statute lists.
Step 3: Treatment and Review
If the court finds the conditions proved by clear and convincing evidence, it can order involuntary treatment for up to 90 days (§ 397.697). A renewal petition must be filed before that period ends, by the service provider or by the original petitioner with supporting documentation from the provider, and a renewal can run up to another 90 days (§ 397.6975).
If a qualified professional determines that he qualifies for early release under the statute’s listed grounds, such as that he no longer needs treatment services, or no longer meets the criteria for involuntary admission and has given informed consent to voluntary treatment, the service provider shall immediately discharge him (§ 397.6971). Discharge planning must cover follow-up appointments, how to get prescribed medications, living arrangements and transportation, and recovery support (§ 397.6977).
Signs That Point Toward a Petition, and What to Gather Now
Start a dated written record of specific events, because the petition must give reasons, not just general worry.
Families often document repeated departures from treatment, overdoses or near-overdoses, dangerous behavior, lost housing, missing money, and refusal of care that is offered. Write down what you saw, when, and who else was there.
Gather these items now:
- Dates and places of each departure, with any discharge paperwork.
- Emergency room, hospital, or police records you can access.
- Names of people who saw the events, and how to reach them.
- Messages where your brother describes his use or his plans.
- Any assessment by a qualified professional done within 30 days before the petition is filed; the petition may be accompanied by that certificate or report.
Treatment records from federally assisted programs have federal confidentiality protections. Sharing them generally requires consent or a court order (federal rules on treatment records). Keep your notes for your own use and for review with a lawyer. Writing facts down now helps you explain them clearly later.
How the Marchman Act Differs From Guardianship and the Baker Act
The Marchman Act addresses substance use impairment, while guardianship addresses an adult who cannot make safe decisions alone.
Florida also has a separate law for mental health crises, called the Baker Act. It is its own law, so a family’s facts may point to it instead of, or alongside, the Marchman Act.
Many families face more than one problem at once. If your brother struggles with money, housing, or medical choices as well as fentanyl, a guardianship question may come up too. Which path fits is a question for the facts of his situation. A consultation can help you sort that out.
Questions Families Ask Before Filing
Most families ask about lawyers, notice, and what happens if he leaves before the hearing.
Do I need a lawyer to file a Marchman Act petition?
A lawyer can help you organize the facts and present them in the form the petition requires.
Will my brother be told I filed?
Yes. A copy of the petition and the notice of hearing must be provided to him (§ 397.68151).
What if he leaves before the hearing?
If he does not appear, the court may issue or reissue an ex parte assessment order valid for 90 days. It may do so when it reasonably believes the criteria are met and an emergency exists (§ 397.6818).
Talk Through Your Brother’s Situation With Our Firm
A short conversation with our firm can show whether a Marchman Act petition fits the facts you have.
You may be worn out from crisis calls and trying to protect someone who doesn’t see the danger. That is a hard place to stand. You don’t have to work through the legal side alone.
Robinson Casey limits practice to Marchman Act petitions and guardianship matters, serving families across South Florida and statewide. Richard J. Casey III, Esq. is responsible for this page.
The first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation to continue. Call (561) 849-4149 or contact Robinson Casey to talk through your loved one’s situation.
Related Guides on Involuntary Commitment for Addiction
The parent guide gives an overview of involuntary commitment for addiction in Florida.
- Involuntary commitment for addiction guide
- Miami-Dade involuntary commitment guide
- South Florida involuntary commitment guide
- If your brother is also involved with the criminal justice system, see Marchman Act and pretrial release.
